Consultin' (Mr.) Pepper

Closing the Teach For America Blogging Gap
Oct 25 2010

Teachable Moments

When the word “gay” entered adolescent vernacular as a synonym for “stupid” or “ill-advised,” I equated it to using the word “retarded” in the same context. It bothered me. There was an incident this past winter with two of my friends, one gay and the other straight. One friend called a situation “gay,” and our friend quickly corrected his faux pas.

One friend thought that because the word was already “accepted” in our daily vocabulary, his using the word was not an indication of bigotry or homophobia. However well-intentioned his comment, this passive homophobia reflects a larger trend in much of the United States.

Homophobia in the South is not veiled. I’ve heard of gay teachers hiding their identity for years for fear of being publicly humiliated by their students. It’s happened at my school, and the fact that other teachers don’t respond to these “teachable moments” says more about out educational system than our low test scores. Administrators should speak up and address these problems rather than sweeping them under the rug until we forget about it.

But the other day, young Mr. Pepper decided to address this problem head on. I had my Spanish tests graded, and luckily a large percentage of them were over a B. I saw two of my students wandering in the library, and I decided to play a little prank on them. As two of my best students (both have over a 95%, and both got 100% on this test), I thought it would be funny to pretend that they had not earned a good grade on my test.

I approached them both and asked, with stern teacher eyes, “What do you think you can do next time to prepare for my test?” Flustered, they both spat out, “Study the map, Mr. Pepper! Uh…make flashcards for our vocabulary.” I smiled and handed them their tests, and they both sighed when they say the A+ circled in red on the answer sheet.

“Mr. Pepper,” responded one girl. “Man, that was gay.”

I paused, flabbergasted that a student would dare make that mistake to a teacher. Obviously, it didn’t phase her, probably because other teachers don’t react to it.

“I’m sorry, what was that?” I gave her an opportunity to recognize the error of her ways.

“That’s just gay, Mr. Pepper. Don’t trip us out like that.”

I said in a stern yet understanding tone that although the word “gay” has multiple meanings, she had used it in the wrong context. “It’s offensive to use the word ‘gay’ in a context that means ‘stupid’ or ‘dumb.’”

The student inquired, “That offends you, Mr. Pepper?”

Yes, I told her, it should be offensive to everyone, because it takes a person’s identity and transforms it into a pejorative.

“Is it because you’re gay, Mr. Pepper?”

This little senior high schooler is now interrogating me about my personal identity. I quickly responded, “No, but that doesn’t really matter.”

The rumors spread to other kids. Now, my fate hangs in a homophobic high school limbo where the word “f-g” and “homo” are thrown around as often as the N-word. Teachable moments can turn into nightmares if you don’t have a plan of attack.

7 Responses

  1. Wes

    What would your plan of attack have been, if you’d had one? I’m facing the same situation and it’s becoming something my kids bring up daily.

    • imapepper87

      I guess my plan would have been to answer honestly and then move on, focusing on the subject at hand rather than moving on to something less relevant. But students are way too interested in my personal life already. Good luck! Thanks for the comment!

  2. It may feel like caving or “not right” in some way, but there is no shame to casually hanging some pictures of you and your girlfriend/ ex-girlfriend/ friend who is a girl behind your desk. It tends to deflect that type of thing more thoroughly than you possibly can or want to do verbally. I’ve known several male CMs who’ve dealt with this issue that way.

    Sometimes its all about survival. ;)

  3. neihhien

    It IS offensive to everyone. Sexual orientation does not matter. What you did is inspiring. I am definitely forwarding this to all my friends. I find it appalling she would ask you that right on the spot.

    I guess they haven’t seen these on television.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEpBYKOs3ys

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWS0GVOQPs0

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yzebaOXdWxA

    Thank you for sharing your experience. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

  4. Ami

    I came across that rather disturbing fact last year when I wasn’t prepared to answer those kinds of inquiries calmly and with a prepared answer. This is a topic that I feel INCREDIBLY strong about. I set myself up this year to be able to combat it. There is a “no hate speech” rule in my classroom that encompasses everything from “shut up” to true slurs like “faggot”, “homo”, etc. It’s worked better this year since I came at it hard from the first day. The students we teach do not have a clear understanding of what “hate speech” is beyond the word “nigger”. It’s not just them, but many teachers, administrators and parents were never exposed to any other way of life either. They automatically assume that if you speak out against it, that it must mean you are a part of the “offended” group. It’s an uphill struggle on this issue. But keep presenting the alternatives to them in a way that comes from a logic based stand point and I think you’ll be okay. They are also overly concerned with our personal lives and are not above creating a reality that is anything but the truth. You haven’t asked for advice so take it or leave it as you will, but I would suggest not bringing it up at this point and if the word comes up or one similar or even another hate speech word or phrase to treat it with the same severity you did with these two students. Make it consistent and they will cease trying to connect it to your personal life and will simply equate it with your behavior as a teacher.

  5. Katie

    I had an “interesting” experience with this last year. A student (one I believe that you currently have) called something gay and I quickly corrected him and then had an impromptu discussion with the class about the word and its inappropriate usages. Only one student said that they had ever been corrected by someone for using the word inappropriately. The student then said, “Oh yeah, yeah. I remember now. …told us that we shouldn’t use the word gay, instead we should say that it’s homosexual.” Yeah. Then it turned into an even longer discussion. However, none of the students in that class used the word again in a pejorative way.

  6. Sara Angel

    Good for you! What a very mature way to handle this type of situation. I hope you at least created a bit of cognitive dissonance with the students.

Post a comment

About this Blog

Allons! whoever you are come travel with me!

Region
Mississippi Delta
Grade
High School
Subject
Foreign Language

Subscribe to this blog (feed)